Season by season

Year	Lge	Pld	W	D	L	GF	GA	Pts	GD	Pos
1953	NSL
1954	NSL	20	11	4	5	43	29	26	14	3rd
1955	NSL	18	5	8	5	25	25	18	0	6th
1956	NSL	24	16	2	6			34		2nd
1957	NSL	27	18	5	4	59	31	41	18	1st
1958	NSL	28	17	5	6	51	26	39	25	2nd
1959	NSL	26	14	8	4	47	36	36	11	2nd
1960	NSL	24	17	3	4	66	31	37	35	1st

National Soccer League Play Offs

1956
Semi Final
Oct 08 v Tridents (?) ?-?
Final
Oct ?? v Polish White Eagles (H) 1-2 - Attendance 6,000
Oct 28 v Polish White Eagles (H) 2-2
Eagles win 4-3 on aggregate

1957
Western Final
Oct 20 v Toronto Hungaria (H) 1-0 - Attendance 6,200
Oct 27 v Toronto Hungaria (H) 1-1
Nov 03 v Toronto Hungaria (H) 1-2
Nov 10 v Toronto Hungaria (H) 2-0
Italia win series 2 games to 1

1958
Final
Oct 19 v Montreal Hungaria (H) 2-2 - Attendance 8,442
Oct 26 v Montreal Hungaria (A) 2-3 - Attendance 3,000
Hungaria win 5-4 on aggregate

1959
Toronto Semi Finals
Oct 07 v Hamilton Italo-Canadians (H)
Oct 11 v Toronto Hungaria (?)
Oct 17 v Toronto Hungaria (?) 3-2
Oct 20 v Toronto Hungaria (?) - Replay
Final
Oct 24 v Montreal Cantalia (H) 1-0
Obt 25 v Montreal Cantalia (H) 1-0
Italia win 2-0 on aggregate

1960
Western Play Off Group
Oct 09 v Hamilton Italo-Canadians (H) 4-0
Oct 10 v Toronto Sparta (H) 2-1
Final
Oct 16 v Montreal Cantalia (A) 2-2 - Attendance 6,000
Oct 22 v Montreal Cantalia (H) 0-0
Oct 23 v Montreal Cantalia (H) 4-2 - Attendance 7,000

Honours
National Soccer League Champions - 1959, 1960
National Soccer League Western Champions - 1957, 1960