Season by season

Year	Lge	Pld	W	L	D	GF	GA	Pts	GD	Pos
2015	L1O	22	4	3	15	24	78	15	-54	10th
2016	L1OW	22	4	3	15	24	67	15	-43	8th
2017	L1OW	22	1	1	20	16	90	4	-74	8th
2018	L1O	16	2	4	10	14	34	10	-20	16th
2019	L1O	15	5	2	8	13	31	17	-18	11th
2020	L1O	Season cancelled due to COVID-19 pandemic
2021	L1OW	12	4	2	6	22	31	14	-9	6th
2022	L1O	21	14	1	6	58	37	43	21	6th
2023	L1O	20	5	4	11	30	51	19	-21	18th
2024	L1OP	22	7	3	12	27	41	24	-14	10th

League1 Ontario Play Offs

2022
Quarter Final
Aug 25 v Alliance United (A) 0-4

League1 Ontario Cup

2015
Group D
Jun 16 v Windsor Stars (H) 2-1 - 1-1 after 90 mins. ProStars win on penalty kicks
Jul 07 v Toronto FC Academy (A) 5-2
Quarter Final
Jul 22 v Durham United (H) 1-1 Durham United win 5-4 on penalties

2016
1st Round
May 18 v Woodbridge Strikers (A) 3-4

2017
1st Round
May 31 v OSU Force (H) 3-4 - Played at Ontario Soccer Centre Stadium, Vaughan, ON

2018
2nd Round
May 27 v Aurora (A) 2-2 - ProStars win 4-3 on penalties
Quarter Final
Jun 23 v Toronto FC III (H) 0-3

2024
1st Round
Apr 21 v Masters FA Saints (H) 1-4